Why ChatGPT recommends established rivals instead of your startup
Last updated
A buyer asks ChatGPT for the best tool in your category and gets five names. None is yours. That is rarely a judgment on your product. The assistant answered from what it could find and what it already knew, and a new company is thin in both. This guide says why it happens, and what a new company can do.
Why it happens
The answer is written from pages that already exist. Asked for options, an assistant searches the web and writes from what comes back. Google’s documentation for Gemini gives the steps: the model “generates one or multiple search queries and executes them”, then “processes the search results, synthesizes the information, and formulates a response” (Grounding with Google Search). Those results are places where other people write about products: review sites, roundups, forums and videos. Most of those pages were written before you launched.
Some answers come from memory, and you are not in it. An assistant doesn’t always search: OpenAI says its model “can choose to search the web or not based on the content of the input prompt” (OpenAI’s web search tool). When it answers from what it learned in training, a company that launched after the model was trained is not in that memory at all.
The list is short. An answer names a handful of options, however many products a market has.
Being written about elsewhere is the strongest pattern anyone has measured. Across 75,000 brands, mentions of a brand on other websites correlated with appearing in Google’s AI Overviews more than anything else studied (0.664), far ahead of backlinks (0.218). The author adds that “correlation ≠ causation” (Ahrefs, May 2025). An established rival has years of reviews, comparisons and forum answers behind it. A new company has a launch post.
What it is not
- Not a verdict on your product. Nothing in the process tries the products.
- Not usually a block on your site. Check anyway, because it is quick: how to check that AI crawlers can read your website.
- Not fixed by a file or a kind of markup. For a page that is indexed and can be shown with a snippet, Google says “There are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode” (AI features and your website).
What a new company can do, in order
- Be readable and indexed. Words in the HTML, crawlers let in, and each page in Google’s and Bing’s index. Nothing else counts until this is done.
- Say what you are in one sentence, the same everywhere. If other companies share your name, an assistant may describe one of them.
- Answer the buyer’s question on your own site. A page for each comparison buyers make, and one that sets your product beside the others fairly. An assistant can only cite a page that exists.
- Get onto the pages the answers already read. Read the sources under the answers to your buyers’ questions. Claim your profile on the review sites among them, ask the author of a roundup to consider you and say why you belong there, and answer questions where your buyers ask them. Real ones only: Google says that “seeking inauthentic ‘mentions’ across the web isn’t as helpful as it might seem” (Google’s guide to generative AI search).
- Ask the same questions again in a few weeks. Not the next day. How long it takes.
Wellread shows this for your company: who ChatGPT and Gemini name on your buyers’ questions, and which sites the answers read. A scan is free and needs no sign-in. Run yours.